Inspired by a question I received earlier today, and a few sites that were brought to my attention recently...
What is so difficult about leaving a link to a website on a piece of software you have received for free? So-called "linkware" script authors don't make a penny from their scripts. All they ask is that you link back to their site, and in most cases will embed a link into the script they provide. Now I know of people who have spent HOURS going through a script simply to remove the credit line. Apparently the script in question (Cutenews) has its credit line encrypted or something and it's very difficult to remove. Cue the person asking on every forum and emailing everyone they know asking 4 OMGZ HLP PLZ, and when told that the credit line couldn't be removed, they decided not to use the script. WTF?! I don't know about you, but doesn't it seem like a lot more effort to go about trying to get rid of the credit than just, oh I don't know, leaving it where it is?
Some script authors will settle for a link on a credits page. I admit, I'd rather find a credit link there than nowhere else, but I still wonder why these people go to all the effort when they really, really don't have to.
Removing credits is one thing, but when you change the credit to reflect a different name or URL? That is beyond unacceptable. I had someone rename PHPAskIt to "GoddessFAQ 1.2". It was blatantly the same script, the same workings, the same layout, everything. When I contacted the site owner I got a rude reply saying the person had spent ages modifying the script and it wasn't even the same any more. Oh really? Somehow I don't think so. Everything on that site appeared to work in exactly the same way as PHPAskIt. I don't think there's even a million-to-one chance that someone could write exactly the same script purely by coincidence.
Anyway. I now have a layout for my CMS admin panel! Woo, it's a little bit easier to manage things around here now. :) I've fixed quite a few bugs as well - blank tags should now display without errors, non-existent pages/posts should no longer display a blank page, etc., etc.
Oh, and going back to PHPAskIt briefly... Version 3 is in the works, and will be out soonish (no definite date yet). If you have any feature requests, please get them to me ASAP :)
...and now back to my dissertation. Yes. Must not procrastinate any longer.
Ooh shiny things! *Wanders off*
Edit: Oh, and if you are going to remove the credit, don't give me some stupid excuse like "yeah well the code isn't that great so I'm going to be replacing it with my own soon". I don't care whether the code is great or not - it's good enough for your hundreds of questions at this very moment (and the last couple of years or so that you've been using it), so put the credit back. And for your information, the code "isn't that great" because you're using one of the very first versions of the script. Maybe if you upgraded you'd have more luck.
I highly doubt you'll be writing something better than what I did (if you are even doing so - if the script was as bad as you say it is, how can you have used it for almost two years?), even though it was the first version of PAI (and I knew NOTHING about security and stuff back then. It was literally a copy and paste of several PHP snippets) - you, person(s) in question, can't even design a website (LOLZ PAGEBUILDERZ!11), let alone a script. But thanks for leaving that insecure version up, I hope you get hacked through it. Idiots.
Malin
23/02/2007 at 18:53
I guess it's because they want to give the image that they made the scripts themselves, morons.
And congrats for making your own CMS! I wish I had the time to sit down and learn that kind of stuff to make my own ;)
Carly
23/02/2007 at 21:10
You sound just like me last year with the dissertation procrastination, I even set up a society for it on facebook.com!
Then, when you get lots of spare time after university, you get a little bored and don't want to play on computers anymore... grr!
valerie
25/02/2007 at 4:00
People are morons :(
Josh(ua/y)
25/02/2007 at 19:44
Why on earth do these morons have anti-link feelings anyway? It's not going to make their site seem less professional - it will do the opposite, we visitors will think "ooh, they've used a script there well and modified it".
Louise
26/02/2007 at 1:58
It's not just scripts: People should stop giving the impression that it's ok to take anything, change it, share it, and forget about the original creator. That is just so mean and unfair. :(
Amanda
26/02/2007 at 6:22
Ditto Valerie. I'd tell you more, but you already know how I feel ;)
Jem
26/02/2007 at 22:14
"blank tags should now display without errors" ..how can something display if it's blank? o.O
Script stealers are fucktards.
Amelie
26/02/2007 at 22:17
^ Tags as in, the category tags... Tags that had no entries/non-existent tags (you know, typing random crap after /tag/ ) used to come up with a big huge SQL/division by zero/OMGWTFBBQ error and I thought it was a little bit ugly ;)
Melissa
1/03/2007 at 21:52
Ugh, lame for someone to do that. "GoddessFAQ" wtf?!
I've worked the credit nicely into my theming for the script, muahaha, I never even considered leaving it off of the page! I was messing with my stylesheet earlier today and the page looks a little wonky now, so I need to fix that...but it's still there and staying there! ^_^
Jem
4/03/2007 at 14:36
I think the problem with linkware scripts is that the people who use them have this mentality that because we're offering it for free, we either don't care what happens with it or are already rich (both in terms of money and site visitors) so leaving a link on the script is of no value. Shitbags.